logoalt Hacker News

bluebarbetlast Monday at 10:38 PM4 repliesview on HN

This question IMO reveals how the abstraction of numbers can imprison our minds.

It literally makes no sense to say, "I prefer to have an extra hour in the evening" (the morning and evening will always have equal numbers of hours). Or "I hate it when it's dark at 5pm" (translation: "I hate when it's dark at 5 arbitrary periods after an arbitrary moment that may be hours either side of solar noon").

My solution: pick the time peg closest to the "correct" one (i.e. standard time) and stick to it. People who want year-round "summer" evenings can continue to have them by the simple expedient of doing what DST forces them (and everyone else) to do already: get up earlier.


Replies

frotaurlast Monday at 10:45 PM

In a world where there isn't work schedule and in general the whole of society's schedule which works around the arbitrary time, I agree with you.

show 2 replies
dagssyesterday at 7:20 AM

It just happens that all recurring scheduled events we use in society is encoded to happen at "$globalDailyOffset + $eventTime".

Then a democratic decision was made to change $globalDailyOffset, that being the most expedient way to change 100000 calendar entries at once.

Everyone is ofc still free to change $eventTime to compensate should if they want to and have the mandate.

I don't see the mind prison...

sailingparrotlast Monday at 10:44 PM

> This question IMO reveals how the abstraction of numbers can imprison our minds.

Is it the abstraction of number that imprison our mind or just the reality of having a job and other social constraint based on all of us agreeing on a time?

When most people can’t leave their job before 5pm, wether it’s dark at 5 or 6 makes a huge difference.

show 1 reply
gonzalohmlast Monday at 11:23 PM

It makes sense when schedules are fixed and time is the only thing we can change. I wouldn't mind switching to standard time if I can change my work schedule to have more light after work. I work from home, I don't care about not having light in the morning