logoalt Hacker News

martythemaniakyesterday at 7:19 PM18 repliesview on HN

Why is the US at war?


Replies

999900000999yesterday at 7:54 PM

America needs to have never-ending perpetual wars to sustain its own economy. If we woke up tomorrow and there was just world peace, and America got rid of its military budget millions of people would probably instantly lose their jobs.

That's the ultimate reason. They could just as easily declare war against Venus and spend hundreds of billions of dollars sending rocks into space and it would have the same net effect. Actually it would be a bit more positive because to my knowledge nobody's really living on Venus right now.

show 1 reply
tarkin2yesterday at 7:39 PM

Because, like Venezuala, they were selling their oil to China, which would allow China to attack Taiwan and take the US's supply of advanced semi-conductors for its weapons and military dominance

show 1 reply
spaghetdefectsyesterday at 8:16 PM

Israel attacked Iran and dragged us into the war as per Rubio: https://x.com/Acyn/status/2028573242173366282

show 1 reply
csoursyesterday at 7:32 PM

"Why?" is the hardest of the questions.

For any particular person, you can tell a story that satisfies "Why?". But for a large number of people, you have to answer "Why?" for one sub-group at a time.

In other words, there's not a single answer that will answer this in a satisfying way.

To answer a different question: It appears that the Israeli government and military wanted to bomb Iran again, and the United States executive branch and military decided to help out. This is an incomplete and unsatisfying answer. Sorry.

show 1 reply
zardoyesterday at 7:23 PM

To bring about the second coming of Jesus Christ.

dexzodyesterday at 7:39 PM

Greater Israel project

Quarrelsomeyesterday at 8:16 PM

because when you give someone the keys to the US military to some people, they lack the imagination to think beyond piracy and raiding.

The war in its current inception is Hamas levels of planning.

1. Do a big attack

2. ????

3. Profit!

Depends of if the Iranian state is weak enough to collapse on its own, because I imagine a land assault in Venezuela or Iran would be a horrific mistake due to the terrain.

show 1 reply
hypeateiyesterday at 7:57 PM

Christian Evangelicals, war hawks, and a voter base that fell for the "peace ticket" talk.

show 1 reply
kraftmanyesterday at 7:24 PM

Distraction

jcgrilloyesterday at 7:30 PM

Midterm elections later this year

MengerSpongeyesterday at 7:27 PM

To occupy media cycles? To start the rapture?

morkalorkyesterday at 8:57 PM

I love that this was downvoted and greyed out. Don't think, don't ask questions. Since when was that part of the hacker ethos?

rebolekyesterday at 7:31 PM

You're asking dangerous questions, comrade.

throwaw12yesterday at 8:02 PM

because of Epstein tapes and blackmail by Israel

gtsopyesterday at 8:25 PM

[dead]

Druponyesterday at 7:58 PM

[dead]

pphyschyesterday at 7:45 PM

According to the Secretary of State Marco Rubio yesterday, we are at war because we knew Israel was going to assassinate Iranian leaders and we would be expected to defend them (and our foreign bases) when they go to war, so we might as well go to war right away. 4D chess.