logoalt Hacker News

qwertoxyesterday at 4:50 PM3 repliesview on HN

> Putting a fake case report on GitHub wouldn't make it any less fake.

Much easier to review for whomever wants to review it.


Replies

NewsaHackOyesterday at 5:14 PM

Do you know what a case report is?

SiempreViernesyesterday at 5:01 PM

Obviously just sending it via email to the reviewers works just fine in practice anyway, the problem is really that they published a summary piece about research that was later retracted, but didn't take down their own article.

drivingmenutsyesterday at 5:16 PM

Would it be easier, though? Medical records (in the US) are covered by HIPAA and, to my knowledge, there is no anonymized canonical record, similar to what we have for legal decision. Without that, how difficult would it be to just "make shit up"?