logoalt Hacker News

D-Machineyesterday at 4:53 PM1 replyview on HN

Ah, look, another smug sneer that ignores the evidence I presented, and makes another circular argument (i.e. that because academics look at rep, this is justified, even though I provided evidence disputing this).

I know what journals are better / not. But reputation only is helpful in letting you ignore trash journals, once you are out of trash land, rep is just not a very meaningful factor, and you have to focus on methodology and substance.


Replies

emil-lpyesterday at 5:33 PM

Where's the evidence you presented?

What are some higher-profile journals that are in fact less trustworthy in many ways?

show 1 reply