logoalt Hacker News

AdieuToLogicyesterday at 2:33 AM5 repliesview on HN

Using Claude to provide a legal definition of "pledge" is unconvincing at best.

> What are the legal protections of a “pledge”?

To answer that question is to first agree upon the legal definition of "pledge":

  pledge
  
  v. to deposit personal property as security for a personal 
  loan of money. If the loan is not repaid when due, the 
  personal property pledged shall be forfeit to the lender. 
  The property is known as collateral. To pledge is the same 
  as to pawn. 2) to promise to do something.[0]
Without careful review of the document signed, it is impossible to verify which form of the above is applicable in this case.

> A pledge is a public commitment or statement of intent, not a binding legal contract.

This very well may be incorrect in this context and serves an exemplar as to why relying upon statistical document generation is not a recommended legal strategy.

0 - https://dictionary.law.com/Default.aspx?selected=1544


Replies

techblueberryyesterday at 2:39 AM

Wait, we know it’s not your definition, because it’s inapplicable.

show 1 reply
mr_toadyesterday at 11:01 AM

> For a personal loan of money

The seven are doing some fancy accounting to pay for their data centers, but I don’t think Larry, Sergey and others are taking out personal loans.

retrochameleonyesterday at 3:00 AM

Your answer is less useful and thought out than the Claude response. Claude actually answers the question in the context in which it's being asked.

show 2 replies
xeonmcyesterday at 3:30 AM

Is it the same kind of pledge as alluded to in the Amber Heard trial?