logoalt Hacker News

bojanyesterday at 3:31 PM7 repliesview on HN

Do they have to be a magic bullet?

Switching from ICE to electric is a much smaller ask than switching from personal cars to... bicycles?


Replies

_heimdalltoday at 12:52 AM

Is it really? Electric vehicles require a lot of resources to produce, and those resources are produced globally and shipped overseas multiple times. The batteries are only expected to hold up for 7-10 years, ask my 2014 Volt how the hybrid battery pack is doing.

I get that a change in lifestyle is more difficult for the individual than a change in what we are buying. My point, though, was that only the former is going to have a much greater impact.

nDRDYyesterday at 3:45 PM

With a correspondingly smaller decrease in CO2 output. We're in a Climate Catastrophe on the edge of Global Tipping Points, remember!

Sarcasm aside, I think this is why people have generally stopped caring as much. What we are being asked to do (buy new shiny things for some estimated small percentage decrease in lifecycle CO2 output) does not match the messaging.

FWIW I cycle almost everywhere.

NicuCalceayesterday at 3:55 PM

Why not encourage people who can reasonably cycle to do so? It's not a magic bullet either, but it's no less magic than EVs.

show 1 reply
microtonalyesterday at 3:54 PM

Switching from ICE to electric is a much smaller ask than switching from personal cars to... bicycles?

Bikes are awesome. I do 95% of my trips by bike. It's healthy, cheap, and has very low amortized emissions. Everybody can repair a bike with a small amount of training.

More countries/cities have to do bike-centric road design.

bluGillyesterday at 3:41 PM

If there was some investment most of us could switch to public transit. The problems people have with transit are mostly around there isn't enough of it to be useful - when /where it is useful people use it.

show 1 reply
queenkjuulyesterday at 4:09 PM

Switched from driving to biking and my life is 10x better, js

alberto467yesterday at 3:43 PM

True but also building a new electric car consumes many order of magnitudes more resources (and it will keep consuming them) compared to a bicycle.

But hey, at least you get to keep 99% of your comfort while making 50% less emissions! (if it really is that much).