logoalt Hacker News

bkoyesterday at 4:59 PM4 repliesview on HN

I thought the world and civilization would collapse because of carbon emissions. It's either serious or it's not. If it's serious then it doesn't really matter right?

It's like you're on a boat that sprung a leak and everyone grabs a bucket. But a few people choose to not help because it's not fair for whatever reason.


Replies

squibonpigyesterday at 5:31 PM

Are you a climate change doesn't matter guy or a china is the climate change causer guy? You can't do both at once.

show 2 replies
reitzensteinmyesterday at 6:44 PM

Nah, the analogy for your argument is:

Two Americans and ten Chinese are on a lifeboat. The Americans are each eating two sandwiches a day and the Chinese are eating one. Supplies are low. You do the math and note that the Chinese sure are eating a lot of sandwiches.

__syesterday at 5:41 PM

To your metaphor, their point is that if everyone is grabbing buckets while someone else is working to spring more leaks, maybe someone needs to set aside their bucket & stop the person springing leaks

thfuranyesterday at 5:08 PM

What?

show 1 reply