alt Hacker NewsI wouldn't consider it a defect in the optimizer; it's doing exactly what it's told to do. It cannot convert an nvarchar to varchar -- that's a narrowing conversion. All it can do is convert the other way and lose the ability to use the index. If you think that there is no danger converting an nvarchar that contains only ASCII to varchar then I have about 70+ different collations that say otherwise.
Can you give an example whats dangerous about converting a nvarchar with only ascii (0-127) then using the index otherwise fallback to a scan?
If we simply went to UTF-8 collation using varchar then this wouldn't be an issue either, which is why you would use varchar in 2026, best of both worlds so to speak.