logoalt Hacker News

throwaway2037 • today at 3:52 AM • 2 replies • view on HN

When I read comments like this, I think about the average Joe who says: "Most people are terrible drivers." Then, someone asks them: "Are you a terrible driver?" They respond: "Of course not. I am an excellent driver." A few people roll their eyes.

    > worthy of an instant ban
First, it is not always possible to identify an LLM-generated comment. There are too many false-positives. Imagine if this system was implemented, and one of your comments was identified as LLM-generated and you were instantly banned. How would you feel about it?

Replies

i_think_so • today at 9:09 AM

Maybe we need a reverse Turing test and award -- humans write things that are indistinguishable from AI slop.

I have no idea what that could be useful for, but since the Turing test is now essentially beaten maybe its usefulness has come and gone too.

> Imagine if this system was implemented, and one of your comments was identified as LLM-generated and you were instantly banned. How would you feel about it?

It sounds like a fast, efficient, inexpensive and foolproof recipe for destroying a community. Let's use that as a future test: anyone who advocates for it is undeniably trying to destroy HN, so they get downvoted to 1 karma and permanently blocked from voting on anything else.

cindyllm • today at 4:57 AM

[dead]