logoalt Hacker News

ceejayozyesterday at 4:35 PM1 replyview on HN

> You mention a comment and I respond and then we get to batteries again.

Yes. Because they're the answer here.

> Also this is getting outside of topic of discussion for me because one of the reasons we want Nuclear or Green energy in general is also the environmental plus the sovereign plus the long term affordability plans.

Good luck with nuclear sovereignty, if that's your concern. How many uranium mines are in the UK?

> Why not Nuclear?

/me gestures at the last 50 years of historical evidence

"Why not try nuclear" is like "why not try communism?" for physics nerds. We have tried it.


Replies

Imustaskforhelpyesterday at 5:40 PM

> Good luck with nuclear sovereignty, if that's your concern. How many uranium mines are in the UK?

I can't speak about UK but considering how cheap Uranium is, can UK not do cost analysis. Uranium is abundant material compared to Oil/Coal.

> /me gestures at the last 50 years of historical evidence

> "Why not try nuclear" is like "why not try communism?" for physics nerds. We have tried it.

Maybe, but I think that, I can speak about the problem within US which I can better explain but US had nuclear fearmongering attempts and Senators passed laws which increased regulations on it to the point that some regulations contradict past regulations.

Nuclear power plants being built on loan in such a flimsy regulatory market was what lead to the downfall essentially within US

Nuclear fearmongering and lobbying efforts from Oil Industry as they are one of the most strong opposers of nuclear energy[0]

Once again, how do I explain this but nuclear produces 3.2x less carbon emissions than Solar[1]

We are able to build hydropower plants, we are able to launch spaceships into moon and outer space. It's definitely possible to build nuclear if lobbying effort decreases.

I'd say that its our dependence on Oil and Coal which have been the problem. I have nothing against solar and that is something that I am saying from the start. At some point we should look towards transition towards nuclear as well. To give up on that would simply not be ideal.

[0]: https://climatecoalition.org/who-opposes-nuclear-energy/

[1]: https://solartechonline.com/blog/how-much-co2-does-solar-ene...

show 1 reply