logoalt Hacker News

curuinortoday at 6:25 PM2 repliesview on HN

Connectionist models have lots of theory by theoreticians explicitly pissed off about Chomsky's assertion that there is an inbuilt ability for language. Jay McClelland's office had a little corkboard thingy with Chomsky mockery on the side, for example. Putting forth even the implicature that the present direct descendants are intellectual descendants of Chomsky is like saying Protestants are intellectual descendants of Pope Leo X.


Replies

seanlinehantoday at 6:45 PM

Perhaps a failure of communication -- I was indeed attempting to say that Chomsky was wrong and his ideas were interesting, but more or less a dead end.

suddenlybananastoday at 6:40 PM

>Jay McClelland's office had a little corkboard thingy with Chomsky mockery on the side, for example.

I've never understood why the idea of linguistic nativism is so upsetting to people.

show 2 replies