logoalt Hacker News

ses1984yesterday at 1:21 PM2 repliesview on HN

Normally you buy into something like SP500 via something like an ETF, something with a very low fee because it’s managed entirely automatically via simple algorithms.

How can you invest in SP500 minus TSLA without racking up exorbitant fees?

Unless such a fund already exists, you’d be managing it yourself and pretty much wiping out any gains any time you rebalanced.


Replies

klodolphyesterday at 5:46 PM

> How can you invest in SP500 minus TSLA without racking up exorbitant fees?

Various options…

1. Direct indexing (requires minimum amount of assets),

2. Certain actively-managed ETFs like GGRW, which is not exactly SP500 minus TSLA but it’s not too far off

3. Buying passively-managed ETFs in sectors that don’t include TSLA,

4. TSLQ, maybe. You get fees and other problems. I wouldn’t.

Direct indexing costs more than ETFs in terms of fees, but there’s apparently some kind of tax loss harvesting that you can do with direct indexing to offset the fees, and some people say you can come out ahead. I don’t understand how tax loss harvesting works at a satisfactory level (I’ve read articles and watched videos, but I think I would need to take an accounting class and really sit down with a spreadsheet before I could say that I understand how direct indexing and tax loss harvesting work together.)

Ntrailsyesterday at 3:07 PM

Oh for sure, not an actual proposal for how to invest