logoalt Hacker News

microtonaltoday at 6:54 AM6 repliesview on HN

Controlling what children do online is a solved problem: Parenting and parental control applications.

Spoken as someone who probably hasn't used iOS/Mac parental controls. It is a hot buggy mess that randomly blocks whitelisted applications as well. We use it, but it is a constant pain. Also a lot of applications only work half, e.g., TV apps blocking off all content rather than only content that is not age-appropriate.

By the way, we were initially firm believers of not using parental controls at all, by limiting time and teaching kids about how to use devices in a healthy way. But a lot of apps (e.g. Roblox, YouTube Shorts) are made to be as addictive as crack, making it very hard for a still not fully developed brain to deal with it.

That said, I absolutely dislike the current lobby for age verification because the goal of Meta et al. seems to be to be to absolve themselves of any responsibility by moving verification to devices and to put up regulatory walls to make it more difficult for potential competitors to enter the market. It is regulatory capture.


Replies

prohobotoday at 8:14 AM

The addiction economy is hard to deal with for anyone - regardless of age. So, I agree this is definitely not a solved problem, but from what I see the only viable way forward is actually to do pretty drastic things like not own a smartphone.

show 1 reply
jollymonATXtoday at 3:36 PM

Why are you giving your children access to any devices, online services, video games, social media?

Seriously. There are mountains of evidence all of this is harmful to developing brains.

show 2 replies
widowlarktoday at 4:33 PM

no need to use parental controls if you simply don't get the child the device.

exe34today at 11:11 AM

Sounds like you need a law to regulate parental controls.....

duxuptoday at 7:20 AM

It’s not a parental controls / software problem. It’s a parents showing self control / parenting and monitoring their children in person thing.

show 2 replies
deafpolygontoday at 7:59 AM

This is as intended.