logoalt Hacker News

wzddtoday at 9:27 AM2 repliesview on HN

He doesn't really even dig into the quality of Spotify's AI DJ apart from pointing out, in a very roundabout way, that it was designed for popular music.

Classical is a harder (or at least different) problem and it's why specialist apps like Apple Music Classical exist.


Replies

earthnailtoday at 11:14 AM

Ex spotifier here.

Classical isn’t harder. It’s just so niche that leadership at spotify never bothered. It has a whole different taxonomy; it’s composer, not performer based etc.

Spotify isn’t against new taxonomies outside of weatern pop music. The India launch, where ragas were super important, shows it. But the Indian market is vastly larger than the small (albeit loud) number of classical music enthusiasts.

All that is to say, it’s a business decision, not a tech or AI problem.

(I really like classical music, too, btw., so please don’t read this as me not respecting that user base.)

show 1 reply
leokennistoday at 10:50 AM

I was about to comment this too.

For someone that explicitly states:

> I don’t listen to pop songs. I prefer music of the 500-year tradition (...)

And who apparently wants to stream music, it is wild he's not subscribed to Apple Music Classical which exactly circumvents all complaints in this article...