logoalt Hacker News

indoleringlast Monday at 11:11 PM2 repliesview on HN

I would really appreciate it if you would respond to my points instead of just moving on to another argument.

Do you hardcode Github and AWS keys in your SSH config? Do you think it would be beneficial to global security if that happened automatically?


Replies

tptaceklast Monday at 11:21 PM

No, we run a fleet with thousands of physicals and hundreds of thousands of virtuals, of course we don't hardcode keys in our SSH configuration. Like presumably every other large fleet operator, we solve this problem with an internal SSH CA.

Further, I haven't "moved on to another argument". Can you answer the question I just asked? If I have an existing internal PKI for my fleet, what security value is a trust relationship with DNSSEC adding? Please try to be specific, because I'm having trouble coming up with any value at all.

throwway120385last Tuesday at 4:44 PM

We also have thousands of devices accessible over SSH and we maintain our own PKI for this purpose as well. We also use mTLS with a private CA and chain of trust, for what it's worth.

It's a solved problem, basically.