logoalt Hacker News

withinrafaeltoday at 6:54 PM2 repliesview on HN

Looks cool, but this site is a bit difficult for me to grok.

I think the table might be slightly inside-out? The Status column appears to show internal pipeline states ("Pending", "In Review") that really only matter to the system, while Findings are buried in the column on the far right. For example, one reviewed patchset with a critical and a high finding is just causally hanging out below the fold. I couldn't immediately find a way to filter or search for severe findings.

It might help to separate unreviewed patches from reviewed ones, and somehow wire the findings into the visual hierarchy better. Or perhaps I'm just off base and this is targeting a very specific Linux kernel community workflow/mindset.

Just my 1c.


Replies

tonfatoday at 7:10 PM

I think it's just a dashboard, not meant to be used as is.

Reviewers are more likely to instead subscribe to get the review inline, and then potentially incorporate that with their feedback.

fdghrtbrttoday at 7:57 PM

> difficult for me to grok

You sound like a troglodyte.