logoalt Hacker News

GorbachevyChaseyesterday at 4:51 AM3 repliesview on HN

So your definition of intelligence would be exactly equal to a human or some subset of them you choose? Could a dog solve ARC-AGI? Probably not. I would not say they lack intelligence. Same with a fruit fly. What if the calculator is powered by actual living neurons? I think you need to know where you actually think the difference between organic machine and intelligence is before making blanket statements.

A modern LLM in a loop with a harness for memory and behavior modification in a body would probably fool me.


Replies

jwpapitoday at 1:05 AM

I don’t doubt he would fool you when your argument is that a fruit fly is not lacking intelligence.

asutekkuyesterday at 6:33 AM

"a harness for a memory" so it still requires external tools to work well. The whole point of this benchmark is to validate the systems can solve problems without any sort of outside help.

Rastonburyyesterday at 11:12 PM

Dogs are just pattern matching based on their training set which is evolution /s