logoalt Hacker News

tdb7893today at 5:31 PM7 repliesview on HN

Trans women have competed as women in the Olympics once ever and have 0 medals. By the numbers it's a non issue under previous rules (despite the incredible amount of ink spilled over it). People are talking about trans women here but the vast majority of people affected by this change are women who are not trans who have a "disorder of sexual development".


Replies

themgttoday at 7:43 PM

The IOC policy is specifically that athletes need to test negative for the SRY gene to be eligible to compete in the female category. Imane Khelif won gold in the 2024 Summer Olympics women's boxing event, and has since admitted to having the SRY gene. So it isn't a non-issue.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imane_Khelif#2026

show 2 replies
canucker2016today at 7:20 PM

The guidelines for trans female athletes for the 2024 Paris Olympics involved transitioning before the age of 12/puberty to be eligible.

There's more info at https://www.independent.co.uk/sport/olympics/paris-2024-olym...

show 1 reply
lewdevtoday at 5:59 PM

Is it fair to say that they can just compete in the men's division?

show 3 replies
mvdtnztoday at 7:20 PM

Almost every single person on Earth is not built of the right genetic stuff to compete with male Olympic athletes, me and you included. Why do we need a carve out for one particular group because of their genetic bad luck?

mothballedtoday at 5:41 PM

The Olympics are looked up to by a large range of people and organization that don't actually participate in the Olympics.

This goes beyond just affecting the Olympics, but setting an example for the world to follow and gives other organizations the cover and courage to follow while being able to deflect to simply setting the same standards of the Olympics.

MengerSpongetoday at 7:03 PM

[flagged]