logoalt Hacker News

EA-3167today at 5:42 PM5 repliesview on HN

That doesn’t seem to be the case, given the first paragraph of the article:

> The International Olympic Committee has barred transgender athletes from competing in the women’s category of the Olympics and said that all participants in those events must undergo genetic testing.

Genetic testing doesn’t leave a lot of room for accidentally or intentionally targeting women for being “insufficiently feminine.”


Replies

lynndotpytoday at 7:07 PM

This might be true if the Olympics were exclusively classifying the 23rd chromosomes, and nothing but.

Leave aside the fact that very few of us here have actually tested our 23rd chromosome. Historically, the Olympics have not been (and are not) strictly chromosomal. The 2023 testosterone suppression decision requirements has exclusively impacted cis women, for one example.

Humans are biologically dimorphic in the same way winters are usually cold and summers are usually hot.

show 2 replies
dragonwritertoday at 5:53 PM

Genetic testing for what?

I'm just going to leave the headline of this article for you to consider while you answer:

"Report of Fertility in a Woman with a Predominantly 46,XY Karyotype in a Family with Multiple Disorders of Sexual Development"

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2190741/

show 1 reply
poizan42today at 5:49 PM

Is the "genetic testing" for the presence of a Y chromosome or the presence of the SRY gene? And what about people with AIS?

If it's just karyotype, are men with XX male syndrome (SRY gene without an Y chromosome) then allowed to participate in women's sports?

show 2 replies
pasquinellitoday at 5:48 PM

wouldn't a woman with a y chromosome be disqualified then?

altruiostoday at 5:46 PM

just going to leave this here for you to read...

https://www.olympics.com/en/news/semenya-niyonsaba-wambui-wh...

show 1 reply