logoalt Hacker News

Schedule tasks on the web

271 pointsby iBelievetoday at 4:47 AM218 commentsview on HN

Comments

gowthamgts12today at 5:14 AM

interesting to see feature launches are coming via official website while usage restrictions are coming in with a team member's twitter account - https://x.com/trq212/status/2037254607001559305.

also, someone rightly predicted this rugpull coming in when they announced 2x usage - https://x.com/Pranit/status/2033043924294439147

show 4 replies
nickandbrotoday at 5:13 AM

I feel like we are just inching closer and closer to a world where rapid iteration of software will be by default. Like for example a trusted user makes feedback -> feedback gets curated into a ticket by an AI agent, then turned into a PR by an Agent, then reviewed by an Agent, before being deployed by an Agent. We are maybe one or two steps from the flywheel being completed. Or maybe we are already there.

show 28 replies
kelvinjps10today at 2:44 PM

I feel like a lot of people and companies wanted to automate the web, but most website's operators wouldn't let you and would block you. Now you put the name AI into and now you're allowed to do It.

simianwordstoday at 6:55 AM

I remember when I tried to set something up with the ChatGPT equivalent like "notify me only if there are traffic disruptions in my route every morning at 8am" and it would notify me every morning even if there was no disruption.

show 4 replies
monkeydusttoday at 7:30 AM

I do feel people will end up using this for things where a deterministic rule could be used - more effective, faster and cheaper. See this starting to happen at work...'We need AI to solve X....no you don't"

show 10 replies
javiercrtoday at 8:13 AM

I've recently switched from GitHub Copilot Pro to Claude Code Max (20x). While Claude is clearly superior in many aspects, one area where it falls short is remote/cloud agents.

Yesterday, I spent the entire day trying to set up "Claude on the web" for an Elixir project and eventually had to give up. Their network firewall kept killing Hex/rebar3 dependency resolution, even after I selected "full" network access.

The environment setup for "on the web" is just a bash script. And when something goes wrong, you only see the tail of the log. There is currently no way to view the full log for the setup script. It's really a pain to debug.

The Copilot equivalent to "Claude on the web" is "GitHub Copilot Coding Agents," which leverages GitHub Actions infrastructure and conventions (YAML files with defined steps). Despite some of the known flaws of GitHub Actions, it felt significantly more robust.

"Schedule task on the web" is based on the same infrastructure and conventions as "Claude on the web", so I'm afraid I'm gonna have the same troubles if I want to use this.

iBelievetoday at 5:18 AM

Looks like I'm limited to only 3 cloud scheduled tasks. And I'm on the Max 20x plan, too :(

"Your plan gets 3 daily cloud scheduled sessions. Disable or delete an existing schedule to continue."

But otherwise, this looks really cool. I've tried using local scheduled tasks in both Claude Code Desktop and the Codex desktop app, and very quickly got annoyed with permissions prompts, so it'll be nice to be able to run scheduled tasks in the cloud sandbox.

Here are the three tasks I'll be trying:

Every Monday morning: Run `pnpm audit` and research any security issues to see if they might affect our project. Run `pnpm outdated` and research into any packages with minor or major upgrades available. Also research if packages have been abandoned or haven't been updated in a long time, and see if there are new alternatives that are recommended instead. Put together a brief report highlighting your findings and recommendations.

Every weekday morning: Take at Sentry errors, logs, and metrics for the past few days. See if there's any new issues that have popped up, and investigate them. Take a look at logs and metrics, and see if anything seems out of the ordinary, and investigate as appropriate. Put together a report summarizing any findings.

Every weekday morning: Please look at the commits on the `develop` branch from the previous day, look carefully at each commit, and see if there are any newly introduced bugs, sloppy code, missed functionality, poor security, missing documentation, etc. If a commit references GitHub issues, look up the issue, and review the issue to see if the commit correctly implements the ticket (fully or partially). Also do a sweep through the codebase, looking for low-hanging fruit that might be good tasks to recommend delegating to an AI agent: obvious bugs, poor or incorrect documentation, TODO comments, messy code, small improvements, etc.

I ran all of these as one-off tasks just now, and they put together useful reports; it'll be nice getting these on a daily/weekly basis. Claude Code has a Sentry connector that works in their cloud/web environment. That's cool; it accurately identified an issue I've been working on this week.

I might eventually try having these tasks open issues or even automatically address issues and open PRs, but we'll start with just reports for now.

show 1 reply
georaatoday at 5:08 PM

Scheduling is easy. The hard part is everything between "started" and "done" - task needs human approval at step 3, fails at step 5 (retry from 4 or from scratch?), takes 6 hours and something restarts. How do they handle tasks that span multiple inference calls? Is there checkpointing or does it start over?

chopete3today at 6:19 AM

Claude is moving fast.

https://grok.com/tasks

Grok has had this feature for some time now. I was wondering why others haven't done it yet.

This feature increases user stickiness. They give 10 concurrent tasks free.

I have had to extract specific news first thing in the morning across multiple sources.

mkageniustoday at 6:00 AM

This is a bit restrictive, doesn't take screenshots. So you can't "say take screenshots of my homepage and send it to me via email"

It doesnt allow egress curl, apart from few hardcoded domains.

I have created Cronbox in the cloud which has a better utility than above. Did a "Show HN: Cronbox – Schedule AI Agents" a few days back.

https://cronbox.sh

and a pelican riding a bicycle job -

https://cronbox.sh/jobs/pelican-rides-a-bicycle?variant=term...

jFriedensreichtoday at 1:40 PM

We need to fight model providers trying to own memory, workflows and tooling. Don't give them an inch more of your software than needed even if there is a slight inconvenience setting up.

show 4 replies
sarpdagtoday at 3:26 PM

I can't pick the effort for the tasks run on Claude Web. I have a feeling Claude is using low or medium effort on those tasks, and I observe clear quality differences with the task ran on my local claude code, which uses high effort.

show 1 reply
0898today at 1:33 PM

One interesting restriction is that it won’t do anything with people’s faces.

I run conferences and I like to have photos of delegates on the page so you can see who else is attending.

I wanted to automate this by having Claude go to the person’s LinkedIn profile and save the image to the website.

But it seems it won’t do that because it’s been instructed not to.

show 1 reply
zmmmmmtoday at 5:29 AM

i'm missing something basic here .... what does it actually do? It executes a prompt against a git repository. Fine - but then what? Where does the output go? How does it actually persist whatever the outcome of this prompt is?

Is this assuming you give it git commit permission and it just does that? Or it acts through MCP tools you enable?

show 2 replies
hirako2000today at 12:04 PM

Oh my, did Anthropic invent Cron jobs as a service?

It's a game changer.

Edit: my mistake. It's inferior to a Cron job. If my repos happen to be self hosted with Forgejo or codeberg, then it won't even work. If I concede to use GitHub though I don't have to set up any env variables. Schedules lock-in, all over the web.

show 4 replies
throwatdem12311today at 12:20 PM

So this is basically just Anthropic’s version of Open Claw that they manage for you and you pay them.

arjietoday at 5:05 AM

What's the per-unit-time compute cost (independent of tokens)? Compute deadline etc.? They don't charge for the Cloud Environment https://code.claude.com/docs/en/claude-code-on-the-web#cloud... currently running?

lucgagantoday at 5:22 AM

Here goes my project.

show 3 replies
pastel8739today at 5:02 AM

Is this free? I don’t see pricing info. I guess just a way to make you forget that you’re spending money on tokens?

show 1 reply
dbvntoday at 1:29 PM

it would be easier to use claude to write a cronjob that does the same thing for you but accurately

show 1 reply
mememememememotoday at 10:33 AM

The PHP script from a cron tab is back!

show 1 reply
PeterStuertoday at 7:18 AM

Is only Github supported as a repository?

Steinmarktoday at 5:16 PM

[dead]

maxbeechtoday at 11:47 AM

[dead]

commers148today at 12:40 PM

[dead]

MeetRickAItoday at 6:49 AM

[dead]

jngiam1today at 5:38 AM

This is powerful. Combined with MCPs, you can pretty much automate a ton of work.

show 1 reply