logoalt Hacker News

sibtain1997today at 11:51 AM1 replyview on HN

The PLAN.md question is the one worth pulling on. Once the plan lives in git or the PR it's already downstream of intent and whoever defined what to build has already handed off. The harder problem is giving agents access to the original intent, not just the implementation plan derived from it. When there's drift between what was planned and what got built, a git-resident PLAN.md makes it hard to trace back to why the decision was made in the first place.


Replies

hrimfaxitoday at 1:40 PM

The plan will always be downstream of intent though. At least in git you can track the evolution of the plan over time and hopefully annotate the rationale for changes in direction.

show 1 reply