logoalt Hacker News

Zakyesterday at 9:25 PM8 repliesview on HN

It's a very small concession. The high initial friction still means when someone comes to me with a problem and I tell them the solution is in F-Droid, they have to wait a day. Most give up and pick a different, less trustworthy solution from Google Play.


Replies

malickatoday at 3:38 AM

Incredibly small concession that doesn’t warrant this article’s absolutely insane framing: “Even less of a problem than we thought,” “very, very good news,” “already sounded perfectly manageable.”

The author is so giddy to defend this monopolistic restriction on Google’s part. Hackers can use F-Droid without annoyance, but this really does kill any chance at normies using it. They absolutely will use the worst spyware on Google Play instead, and the author seemingly loves it.

show 1 reply
andrewaylettyesterday at 9:38 PM

Given the Epic settlement means Google is allowing alternate app stores, and also the delay only applies for unregistered developers, I'm not certain it won't actually get easier to get folk set up on F-Droid.

It still remains to be seen what the actual requirements are, and even if F-Droid could become "approved" that doesn't mean they want to. Time will tell.

show 2 replies
Sophiratoday at 4:33 PM

Not to mention that the "concession", such that it is, will presumably only work if you sign into a Google account. Presumably, this will require that you have Google Play Services installed.

Of course, many people who want to de-Google their phones won't want to do either. This is an attack on people who want to keep their lives separate from Google.

thoiweurewrwetoday at 3:48 AM

The rationale behind this move makes no sense either - most of the scams happen via some instruction to install Anydesk or some such remote-support software, not some shady apkg downloaded from some third party website.

Seems like a move to get around the Epic Games ruling (and assorted rumbles from countries like India).

toast0today at 5:32 AM

Do you have to wait a day, or do you have to set your clock forward a day?

show 1 reply
sunaookamitoday at 8:29 AM

You can bypass the wait time with adb install at least.

show 1 reply
danpalmertoday at 3:32 AM

I'm biased, but I don't think less trustworthy is a fair assessment. I think you can suggest that open source software provides a different trust model than closed source and distributed by Play, but to conclude it's less trustworthy is a real stretch.

show 1 reply
tasukitoday at 9:48 AM

> have to wait a day

The horrors!