logoalt Hacker News

999900000999yesterday at 1:51 PM1 replyview on HN

I don’t understand this authoritarian need to ban everything you don’t like.

Should the government have a reparability board ? Who gets to be on it ?

If it pleases the King , may I buy a laptop while traveling and bring it home.

An argument could be made for a refundable recycling fee. Say 5% that gets returned when you take the device to a recycling center after your done with it


Replies

streetfighter64yesterday at 3:08 PM

I mean, do you also consider it "authoritarian" to have e.g. regulations on vehicle exhaust? Should the government have an environmental protection agency? Who gets to be on it? What about my right to insulate my house with asbestos and paint it with lead?

And who's talking about banning private import of laptops? You do know that you can regulate national sales without controlling absolutely everything right? Whoever bothers to travel to a different country just to buy a worse laptop should be allowed to do so, it's whatever.

Regarding "recycling", that's all a show in order to seem more environmentally friendly with very little actual impact. You can look up how electronics "recycling" usually works in practice, which normally entails sending the waste to third world countries to have some precious metals extracted using dangerous and not exactly environmentally friendly processes.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vufLW4xOsS4

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CJ8BjHOdI8g

show 1 reply