logoalt Hacker News

skeledrewtoday at 2:54 AM1 replyview on HN

Strange. I've never experienced verbosity with Claude. It always gets right to the point, and everything it outputs tends to be useful. Can actually be short at times.

ChatGPT on the other hand is annoyingly wordy and repetitive, and is always holding out on something that tempts you to send a "OK", "Show me" or something of the sort to get some more. But I can't be bothered with trying to optimize away the cruft as it may affect the thing that it's seriously good at and I really use it for: research and brainstorming things, usually to get a spec that I then pass to Claude to fill out the gaps (there are always multiple) and implement. It's absolutely designed to maximize engagement far more than issue resolution.


Replies

peacebeardtoday at 3:51 AM

My experience is that Sonnet can be a bit verbose and prompting it to be more succinct is tricky. On the other hand, Opus out of the box will give me a one word answer when appropriate, in Claude Code anyway.