logoalt Hacker News

tokailast Friday at 3:15 PM7 repliesview on HN

Prisoner of war, not hostage.

edit: I'm baffled by the amount of downvotes pointing out the objectively correct terminology can get. Its not a matter of opinion, military personnel captured by the enemy are pow no matter their treatment. A hostage, by definition, has been abducted.


Replies

ks2048last Friday at 6:42 PM

Not a Prisoner of War - a Prisoner of a limited military excursion.

show 3 replies
andrewflnryesterday at 12:30 AM

I don't know what definition of "hostage" you're using, but practically speaking, a hostage is what you make of them.

jimnotgymyesterday at 2:58 PM

I guess the down goes is because war has not been declared? Therefore they captured a what, war criminal, foreign terrorist?

postsantumyesterday at 12:27 AM

> He was kidnapped from his warplane

spwa4last Friday at 3:20 PM

That is assuming Iran holds itself to the Geneva conventions, which ... seems like an extremely risky bet to make.

show 10 replies
NickC25last Friday at 4:04 PM

...but we aren't at war, according to the President and his secretary of Defense (war).

what a fucking mess.

MarkMarinelast Friday at 3:39 PM

It’s a “well, actually” and counter to the HN guidelines

show 2 replies