logoalt Hacker News

ceejayozyesterday at 3:25 PM5 repliesview on HN

> The ruling, awarded without proper notice by an emergency arbitrator (a non-court mediator that is part of the American Arbitration Association), actually said nothing about the truth or otherwise of Sarah’s devastating claims in her book. It made no mention of defamation. Instead, it relied on a non-disparagement clause in her severance agreement with Facebook to silence her.

It's well past time to rein in arbitration.

It really should be treated like small claims court; only permissible up to a point. Once it's high-stakes enough, real courts should be in play.


Replies

pants2yesterday at 3:39 PM

So what happens if the author ignores this judgement? Surely arbitration can't send someone to prison. According to the web they still need a court to even confirm a monetary penalty.

show 1 reply
ethinyesterday at 3:48 PM

Honestly, I would be all for outright abolishing arbitration. I have yet to see anything actually good come out of arbitration other than a ruling that protects the entity that forced arbitration in the first place.

show 1 reply
vr46yesterday at 4:55 PM

Public interest argument is strong here

Invictus0yesterday at 3:32 PM

she agreed to it to get a severance payment

show 3 replies
sieabahlparkyesterday at 4:20 PM

[dead]