logoalt Hacker News

pwdisswordfishyyesterday at 4:33 PM2 repliesview on HN

It should not be legal to enforce full stop. If you don't want to be disparaged, make your conduct worthy of not being disparaged. When you're being lied about, sue for defamation; "non-disparagement clauses" are redundant at best, an attack on free speech at worst.


Replies

mathgradthrowyesterday at 4:45 PM

You don't have to agree to a disparagement clause... She accepted a lot of money to agree to it.

show 3 replies
SpicyLemonZestyesterday at 5:06 PM

The reason they’re not redundant is that we, rightly, don’t allow people to sue for defamation for many kinds of unfair speech and even some kinds of untrue speech. It’s not defamatory for you to call me careless or mean or rude, even if I can produce ironclad proof that you know I’m careful and kind.