logoalt Hacker News

matthewdgreenyesterday at 5:15 PM1 replyview on HN

If we require every whistleblower to be a saint, then we’ll never hear a whistle. If you have a serious criticism of their credibility, that’s potentially different, but arbitrary criticisms of someone’s moral worth is mostly irrelevant.


Replies

RHSeegeryesterday at 6:29 PM

The fact that someone actively worked against the welfare of society as a whole, in significant and impactful ways, _is_ a criticism of their credibility. It speaks to their morals and empathy for others.

It doesn't mean that what they're saying is a lie, but it puts them firmly in the bucket where what they say needs to be verified.

show 1 reply