logoalt Hacker News

spwa4last Saturday at 7:30 PM0 repliesview on HN

Why is it so hard to accept the basic fact that Iran - and Palestine (and China, and Russia, and Cuba, and ...) do not allow free press or free communication? That means with rare exceptions (unless someone is willing to risk their life for it) you ONLY have access to propaganda.

In any society that doesn't allow free press:

ANY television broadcast = government propaganda

Red Cross/Crescent = disguised government propaganda (Hamas/Iran's islamist regime)

ANY internet message = disguised government propaganda

ANY story published in the BBC with sources from that country = disguised government propaganda

ANY information delivered by anyone who wasn't risking their lives = disguised government propaganda

ANY information delivered by a foreign journalist "invited" into the country (ie. CNN in this conflict) = government propaganda (like "embedded journalists" in US army)

You do not have ANY information from within Iran except propaganda and very rare, very incomplete viewpoints (slowly) anonymously smuggled out. That's it. Yes, this means you generally just do not know. Not even if "the Red Cross/Crescent" says so, because they cannot risk saying anything but the government's viewpoint.

I get that this is very hard to understand for someone living in the US or Europe but that's how it is.

This was the case in the cold war with all the communist regimes. This is currently the case with Russia. With Cuba. With China. And, of course, with Iran. There is no information BUT propaganda from both sides. Nothing but that.

And sorry to point out the obvious, but given the choice between the US army and Iran's mullahs ... even Trump beats the islamist mullahs in reliability and credibility. Yes this is choosing the best option between Syfilis and Gonorrhea. But Trump wins that contest. Easily. Hands down.