logoalt Hacker News

erutoday at 12:25 PM2 repliesview on HN

Well, Plato's sock puppet Socrates famously opposed writing with pretty much these arguments.


Replies

plastic-enjoyertoday at 12:43 PM

No, he did not and it would be good if people would have _actually_ read Plato's Phaedrus before regurgitating the same nonsense every time someone has a critical perspective on LLM writings.

show 1 reply
Brendinoootoday at 12:29 PM

Yup.

And to be clear, maybe some things were genuinely lost when we switched to the written word. But I have to believe it was a net gain.

Time will tell if that's true here as well.