logoalt Hacker News

Lercyesterday at 3:13 PM1 replyview on HN

I cannot find a single action of anyone that cannot be construed as an attempt to get them power/money/influence. I can believe that a persons intentions are good, but I can't make everyone in the world do that, and that is what you are asking.

"If you give me six lines written by the hand of the most honest of men, I will find something in them which will hang him"

To play your game, he got married, had a child, and joined an AI research organisation at a time when everybody thought the big advances were much further away than they turned out to be.

You could still construe those actions as evil if you choose to see them as evil.

I'm not going to claim that Sam Altman is not a sociopath, I lack the information and knowledge of psychology to make that determination. On the other hand I have not detected those attributes in anyone who has claimed he is a sociopath.

It seems odd that people seem to take offense at the notion that arbitrary people do not reach a conclusion that requires specialised expert knowledge and a decent amount of irrefutable evidence.


Replies

rglullisyesterday at 3:45 PM

> I cannot find a single action of anyone that cannot be construed as an attempt to get them power/money/influence

Try the other way around, via negativa. We definitely can find plenty of examples of people stepping out of positions of power, deciding not to do something because of moral conflict, etc. Is there any case of such action from Sam?

Fuck, anyone with any semblance of moral fortitude would refuse to take money from the Saudis. But he had no problem to do it.

> joined an AI research organisation at a time when everybody thought the big advances were much further away than they turned out to be.

No, this is selection bias. What he did was to put himself in a position where he could have his fingers on any and every possible pie, and then when of these things turned out to be something believed to be valuable by people with money, then he manouvered himself to be in the driver seat.