logoalt Hacker News

hackerman70000today at 4:17 PM3 repliesview on HN

This reads like cope. If taste were a real moat, designers and art directors would be the highest paid people in tech. They arent. Execution speed, distribution, and capital are moats. Taste is a tiebreaker at best. The market consistently rewards "good enough, shipped fast" over "exquisite, shipped late".


Replies

hackable_sandtoday at 8:41 PM

I guess so

If your goal is to turn a profit

If you want to make something that is true then you can't fail. You don't need any defensive structures because the everyone else just spins in lies.

People only need moats when they are insecure, by definition

The most truthful artists don't need that.

DrewADesigntoday at 4:30 PM

It’s not that straightforward. Art directors and designers get paid to visually communicate things the business wants to communicate— anything from brand vibes, to directing people to click on a “buy me” button, to the state of an interface. Most designers in tech companies aren’t even the ones that design things like branding — that’s done by specialists in extremely well-compensated studios, and corporate designers are stuck following their guidelines. Taste is nearly irrelevant to an interface designer, for example.

show 1 reply
ata_amantoday at 4:29 PM

I maintain the opinion that courage is the only moat and always will be

show 1 reply