logoalt Hacker News

ethanj8011today at 3:34 PM2 repliesview on HN

Isn't the point that unless actually audited each time, the code could still be effectively anything?


Replies

woodruffwtoday at 3:45 PM

Yes, but that's already the case. My point was that in practice the current discrepancies observed don't represent a complete disconnect between the ground truth (the source repo) and the package index, they tend to be minor. So describing the situation as "nobody knows what 17% of the top crates.io packages do" is an overstatement.

show 2 replies
echelontoday at 4:24 PM

Serious consideration: Claude Mythos is going to change the risk envelope of this problem.

We're still thinking in the old mindset, whereas new tools are going to change how all of this is done.

In some years dependencies will undergo various types of automated vetting - bugs (various categories), memory, performance, correctness, etc. We need to think about how to scale this problem instead. We're not ready for it.