And Java typically does produce both (see Exception "cause" field). So when an exception stack trace is printed it's actually list of stacktraces, for each "cause". You can skip stacktraces and just concatenate causes' messages (like people often do in Go).

So the full message would be like "Cannot add item X to cart Y: Error connecting to warehouse Z: Error establishing TLS connection to example.com 127.0.1.1: PKIX failed".

Sounds to me that deepsun and I are in agreement that an error message should tell you what the actual error was.

I.E. ERROR: TLS handshake failed: <DOMAIN> certificate chain unverified

This is why stack traces exist. But I agree Java seems to not really have a culture of “make the error message helpful”, but instead preferring “make the error message minimal and factual”.

For what it’s worth, the rise of helpful error messages seems to be a relatively new phenomenon the last few years.