logoalt Hacker News

skydhash04/12/20261 replyview on HN

> Developers weren't so much "following design idioms" as "doing what is easy to do on Windows".

Most people only uses one computer. Inconsistency between platforms have no bearing on users. But inconsistency of applications on one platform is a nightmare for training. And accessibility suffers.


Replies

hn_throwaway_9904/12/2026

I don't disagree, but my point was about the author's incorrect diagnosis of the reason (and solution) for the problem, not that the problem doesn't exist.

As a sibling commenter put it, previously developers had "rails" that were governed by MS and Apple. The very nature of the web means no such rails exist, and saying "hey guys, let's all get back to design idioms!" is not going to fix the problem.