alt Hacker News> Except there isn't any concept of a remote jj so you have to go through the painful steps of manually naming commits, pushing, pulling, then manually advancing the current working point to match.
All true. I ended up writing my own `jj push` and `jj pull` aliases that automated all this. They aren't simple aliases, but it worked. `jj push` for example "feels" very like `git push --force-with-lease`, except if you've stacked PR's it pushed all branches your on. It hasn't been a problem since.
I ended up wondering if they deliberately left the `jj pull` and `jj push` commands unimplemented just so you could write something custom.
> All files automatically committed is great until you accidentally put a secret in an unignored file in the repository folder.
jj abandon COMMIT && jj git garbage-collect
True, but how is this different to any other VCS?
> True, but how is this different to any other VCS?
What other VCS behaves this way by standard? If it's not in e.g. .gitignore "git status" will show that it's aware of it, but won't automatically absorb them into the commit? https://github.com/jj-vcs/jj/issues/5596 doesn't seem to be the oldest instance of this problem, but does seem to be the current discussion, and there seems to be no consensus on how to fix.
Oh, and ISTR submodules were a pain to work with.
Edit: https://github.com/jj-vcs/jj/issues/323#issuecomment-1129016... seems likely to be the earliest mention of this problem