logoalt Hacker News

eucycloslast Wednesday at 5:36 AM6 repliesview on HN

This touches on something I've been thinking about. I'm making an ad blocker that tries to replace native ads with ads that actually add value to the viewer's life. In the public version, I'd like to offer some of the profits to the web hosts even if they haven't heard of it. Do you have any thoughts on how it would be best to go about that?


Replies

sphlast Wednesday at 6:42 AM

The only good ad is no ad.

To engage with your question, the only way to truly, objectively ‘add value to one’s life’ is to become intimately familiar with them, their habits and everything they do on- and offline to understand what they need. This is the entire modus operandi of the current ad industry.

show 1 reply
everdrivelast Wednesday at 12:59 PM

I don't want your product, and I don't want ads. "But ads are what supports XYZ!" I don't care. I don't want it. Whatever you think will crumble away without advertisements, let it all fade away into nothing.

proxlast Wednesday at 7:15 AM

Something I was thinking about was a simple tip jar system. You can add credits to a tipjar system, and if you like a post, site, or whatever you can gift credits.

Completely gets rid of ads that nobody likes anyway.

You could maybe automate it say “if I spend more than 30 seconds on page, pay x credits”

master-lincolnlast Wednesday at 11:04 AM

An ad means somebody paid to get my attention. I never want that. Go away with your ads that need even more tracking...

duskdozerlast Wednesday at 8:37 AM

What do you consider to be an ad that actually adds value to the viewer's life in contrast to other ads?

show 1 reply
kuboblelast Wednesday at 6:22 AM

This doesn't exist.

The ads are only good in a context when I'm searching for particular product.

When I'm trying to do my work then any ad that takes my attention has negative value.

Show me the same ad when I'm actually searching for a new vacuum cleaner and we're fine.

show 1 reply