logoalt Hacker News

DerSaidinyesterday at 9:25 PM4 repliesview on HN

> Cybersecurity looks like proof of work now

Imo, cybersecurity looks like formally verified systems now.

You can't spend more tokens to find vulnerabilities if there are no vulnerabilities.


Replies

jlduggertoday at 6:27 AM

I misread the title as "proof work" not "proof _of_ work." The analysis makes sense, but has kinda always been true. So mostly depressing rather than insightful.

But part of me has been wondering for a while now whether proofs of correctness is the way out of the NVIDIA infinite money glitch. IDK if we're there yet but it's pretty much the only option I can imagine.

deepsunyesterday at 10:50 PM

Every formal verification depends highly on requirements. It's pretty easy to make a mistake in defining the task itself. In the end, you'd want to verify system behavior in real world, and it's impossible to completely define real world. You always make some assumptions/models to reason within, and it impossible to verify the assumptions are correct.

AlexCoventrytoday at 3:58 AM

I think there's definitely more scope for ruling out vulnerabilities by implementing simpler designs and architectures.

drdreyyesterday at 9:55 PM

good luck formally verifying everything

show 1 reply