logoalt Hacker News

Gestelast Wednesday at 11:00 PM2 repliesview on HN

Sometimes, I feel like conversation is just a way to talk to oneself, by using others as mirrors of what we want to believe. That article had that vibe.

I don't care about the show, the author doesn't know why she cares that much about the show, and I really, really don't understand what caring has to do with seeing the same show several times.

>Whenever somebody asks why, I don’t have a good answer.

I'll suggest the author (and everyone reading this) to really, really sit down and think of why they like the things they like. What are the variables that clicked for me when I interact with X ? The theme ? The way the thing is made ? The echo and specific resonance it has with my inner life ?

I would have gained much more from that article if the author had gone to the trouble of making me connect with the show in that way.


Replies

card_zeroyesterday at 11:09 AM

"It's a story about friendship", and it's moving. Everything else, and the reason for seeing it twelvety times, seems in fact to be about communing with real-life friends, and only incidentally about the show.

What's that line from Saki ... to whom anything was thrilling and amusing if you did it in a troop.

dcminteryesterday at 1:55 PM

The author says:

> I’d recommend you go to the show if you haven’t already, but that’s not really the point of this post.

So while I agree that it is good to contemplate why you like things, that wasn't the topic of the post at all.

The author quite explicitly say so.