logoalt Hacker News

markbaoyesterday at 9:04 PM2 repliesview on HN

I don’t really buy that Claude Design will remove all the complexity around design. Vibe-coded apps using Claude look simpler because they are simpler. They’re not a gigantic product suite with extremely specific UI components tailored to each use case. The ‘simplicity’ is an illusion coming from conflating the complexity of a bicycle (a vibe coded app) with an airplane (an app like Figma).

Building the same design system component in code versus in Figma is going to be slightly more succinct in code; Figma’s primitives don’t have the sort of conditionals and control flow that code has. But code is much less malleable than drawing on a screen, and creative freedom is harder to achieve in code.

UI can fix the gap where code feels less malleable than Figma, but complexity comes largely from the worlds that humans create, and humans apparently want to create 8 modes for 4 products and 2 light/dark modes. If you want the same setup in Claude, it’ll be a little easier to maintain, but not much less complex.


Replies

chr15mtoday at 1:07 AM

Making the complexity simpler is the whole thing. Any software that does it wins.

juliusceasaryesterday at 9:45 PM

Most of the times people just want a bike or a car. Not everybody needs an airplane. This is going to hit Figma very hard.

show 7 replies