logoalt Hacker News

jjk166last Sunday at 3:51 AM3 repliesview on HN

> And those fluent in languages that have additional distinct color names can differentiate subtle differences in the shades of colors that non-speakers cannot even differentiate.

The ability to label more colors is not the ability to perceive more colors. The ability of your cone cells to recognize a difference in color between two samples is unaffected by language.


Replies

davidmurdochlast Sunday at 12:23 PM

Your cone cells do not perceive anything whatsoever. Your brain does that part. Those who grew up with words (meaning) assigned to subtle variations in colors can tell those colors apart without a reference to compare it to better than, and much faster than those who haven't grown up with learning the distinction.

We know this to be obvious of sounds, musicians who can tell if a note is slightly out of tune when others who haven't learned how can't, or taste/smell: wine connoisseurs who can tell very similar wines apart that all taste the same to me.

You're not thinking in photons. Your brain is making up meaning from the stimulation your eye received from photons. The perceiving part is learned.

show 1 reply
joquarkylast Sunday at 6:03 PM

I remember back when I thought that perception was this simple.

show 1 reply
c22last Sunday at 5:28 AM

I think you are correct, but the likelihood of perceiving probably is tied to language.

It's amazing how much time we spend on autopilot.

show 1 reply