logoalt Hacker News

wiseowiseyesterday at 9:54 AM2 repliesview on HN

The difference is that there was (at least an illusion of) choice. Nobody said that it is a perfect system. And Trump will be gone in 3 years, while Putin and Xi will stay in power until their death.


Replies

spaceman_2020yesterday at 10:07 AM

I don't understand why Americans continue believing that democracy is the only way for every population in the world

Why would Russians want democracy? Or the Chinese, for that matter? There have been zero democratic impulses in their societies across hundreds, even thousands of years.

The west needs to rest its democratizing mission and accept that every society is fundamentally different

My country (India) got a "thriving" democracy, but because there is no real democratic impulse in the society, everything on the ground has devolved into what the society was always like - quasi-feudal bureaucracy

show 7 replies
cycomanicyesterday at 10:29 AM

At some point I saw an analysis that looked at the policy/political differences between the different fractions of the Chinese communist party and compared them to the spread in a western parliament (I don't remember which one I think US or UK). They found that the spread was very similar. With that I'm not saying that the Chinese system is better, just that these statements are not as straight-forward as one things.

I think a much better metric is suppression of dissent, human rights records etc., not (the illusion of) choice at the poll booth once every 4 years.

show 2 replies