logoalt Hacker News

FooBarWidgetyesterday at 3:12 PM2 repliesview on HN

I find western obsession with "being able to critique X" very weird because it stops at just that. There's very little attention paid to whether the critique produces useful outcomes. While cost of living, energy scarcity, employment, education, wars, etc are all getting worse, people focus on being able to insult the president as the ultimate freedom, even when that achieves nothing.

Meanwhile in China, you can't change the ruling party but you can change policies. They restrict media and speech freedom, but they also work tirelessly to improve the livelihoods of the people.

If the west chooses the value empty talk over outcomes, fine, you have the right to choose that. But no need to force that value on other societies. China and Chinese society at large has the right value unity and livelihood over speech. They have the right to prefer what westerners call an "authoritarian" government that delivers on those values, without getting demonized. They're not forcing their way on you, no need for you to force your way on them.


Replies

kelnosyesterday at 11:38 PM

> they also work tirelessly to improve the livelihoods of the people.

They work to improve the livelihood of people with the same background and ideology, you mean.

0xDEAFBEADyesterday at 3:30 PM

Agreed.