logoalt Hacker News

nonethewiseryesterday at 5:00 PM3 repliesview on HN

its just waaaaaay easier to distribute a web app

For some things a desktop app is required (more system access) or offers some competitive UX advantage (although this reason is shrinking all the time). Short of that user's are going to choose web 95% of the time.


Replies

mohamedkoubaayesterday at 5:41 PM

This points to our failure as an industry to design a universal app engine that isn't a browser.

show 6 replies
rustcleaneryesterday at 8:46 PM

>or offers some competitive UX advantage (although this reason is shrinking all the time).

As a user, properly implemented desktop interface will always beat web. By properly, I mean obeying shortcut keys and conventions of the desktop world. Having alt+letter assignments to boxes and functions, Tab moves between elements, pressing PageUp/PageDown while in a text entry area for a chat window scrolls the chat history above and not the text entry area (looking at you SimpleX), etc.

Sorry, not sorry. Web interface is interface-smell, and I avoid it as much as possible. Give me a TUI before a webpage.

forestoyesterday at 8:00 PM

> its just waaaaaay easier to distribute a web app

Let's also remember that it's infinitely easier to keep a native app operational, since there's no web server to set up or maintain.

show 1 reply