logoalt Hacker News

ssl-3yesterday at 10:19 PM1 replyview on HN

A sampling rate of 192kHz is overkill. And 192KHz exists as a sample rate in audio world because it is overkill.

With a Nyquist frequency of ~96KHz, all of the arguments about whether a person can hear up to eg 22.05KHz, 24KHz, or if there's something meaningful all the way up at 48KHz, become completely and totally ameliorated.

Those arguments were always such tiresome ordeals.

The cost of dissolving those arguments is just some some bandwidth and CPU cycles -- which is to say, it costs approximately nothing.

Please let the man cook. :)


Replies

mattclarkdotnetyesterday at 11:01 PM

Oh it's worse than that, for distribution and playback sampling at more than 48kHz is likely worse in many ways due to unwanted ultrasonic noise and increased intermodulation distortion. 96/24 makes sense for production, and 96/float56 is common in DSP chains.

show 1 reply