logoalt Hacker News

tedd4uyesterday at 6:39 PM3 repliesview on HN

GitHub is going to go after this too (unsurprisingly). Working "Ace" prototype from Github "lab."

https://maggieappleton.com/zero-alignment/


Replies

shotoday at 5:30 AM

The problem description is spot on, but the solution isn't. No-one is going to sit in that chat and "collaborate" on each other's stuff in real time all day. You may as well just all sit around a screen.

I welcome the experimentation, there will definitely be something new, but this ain't it. New primitives are needed, at a higher level of conceptualization, not merely a fancy new interface.

godelskitoday at 2:56 AM

  > writing code is now fast, it's getting cheaper, and quality is going up to the right
I'm unconvinced... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47939579
show 1 reply
anicepersonyesterday at 8:49 PM

the presenter is pretty sane, but the product is hardly a product at the current scenario. pretty much codemirror 6 collaborative editing demo + vm running claude code, with a web GUI. will fall apart with large code bases just like vscode, github codespaces and co. do, and expensive for llms to run against. Would be nice to see the foundational problems being worked on instead of regurgiting what everybody is doing.