logoalt Hacker News

johnfntoday at 1:23 AM2 repliesview on HN

First of all, super cool. I have a soft spot for SimTower as well. :)

> I didn’t want to do a function-by-function port. First, APIs may be copyrightable - and copying a binary that closely might implicate copyright more than an approach closer to clean-room design. But it was clear that I needed some level of feedback from the ground-truth binary in order to provide a hill for the LLM to climb on the reimplementation.

Interesting, but isn't this what, say, the Ocarina of Time reverse engineer port does[1]? I imagine the fact that this hasn't been served a takedown notice from Nintendo is a proof that it's defensible? Or at least that there's precedent, ha.

Anyway, this is really cool. I genuinely think the only thing that's missing for me to waste an afternoon here is the sound effects!

[1]: https://github.com/zeldaret/oot


Replies

MrDOStoday at 11:16 AM

> APIs may be copyrightable

Didn't Google v. Oracle disprove this?

show 1 reply
charcircuittoday at 8:53 AM

It is not proof. It is a clear derived work infringing on the copyright of Nintendo.

show 1 reply