logoalt Hacker News

jstanleytoday at 5:03 AM4 repliesview on HN

lahfir, I vouched your (currently still dead) comment because it was interesting to me.

I expect the reason it is dead is that it seems LLM-generated (you "quietly" launched it on github? Who says that?).

Also, your comment claims that the tool is cross-platform and implies that it works on Mac, Windows, and Linux, but the graphic on the github README says it only works on Mac.


Replies

nerdsnipertoday at 6:24 AM

It looks hybrid human/LLM at best, but definitely possible that it's mostly human, from someone who is earnestly learning how to use "pitch" language. I got the feeling that some parts, like the bullet points, maybe originated from AI-generated documentation/readme's.

My intuition tells me that it could have been AI-generated, but if that's the case then it was heavily edited by a human. I think anyone who went through it for that would have changed other things as well. That's why I suspect it's pseudo-artificial pitch "coded" human writing with some (mostly, lightly edited) copy/paste of AI bullet points.

Then again, I can't find snippets of this language in the repo, so maybe I'm losing my discernment as LLMs advance (as well as the humans who are learning how to use them).

show 1 reply
preommrtoday at 6:37 AM

Wouldn't the opposite be true? That an llm would use well-known terms for general purpose writing. I think it's much more likely that a human would remember 'silent' launch, or 'stealth' launch, and use silent as a substitute.

I feel very strongly that comment wasn't AI generated.

Also, there's a bunch of normal comments that seem to be wrongfully flagged.

show 1 reply
vascotoday at 6:38 AM

3 fake comments in the thread also

handfuloflighttoday at 6:48 AM

Why is Claude always pointing out or assuming what is done quietly?