logoalt Hacker News

bongripperyesterday at 12:27 PM3 repliesview on HN

[flagged]


Replies

Eddy_Viscosity2yesterday at 2:42 PM

Medical professionals have a history of not necessarily having complete understanding of the maths they use in their work. Classic example of a nutritionist 'inventing' the trapezoid rule for calculating area under a curve, and then naming it after herself. And then many many other medical people unironically using said method and citing her.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tai%27s_model

show 2 replies
kelipsoyesterday at 6:30 PM

A lot of people posting here are researchers too, and some have reviewed and published Nature articles too.

JadeNByesterday at 2:46 PM

That seems awfully like an appeal to authority. Your parent comment doesn't just vaguely snipe, but points out reasons this should have been expected. Those reasons could potentially not be valid, or not present the whole picture, but "the researchers are from Stanford" doesn't rebut them.