logoalt Hacker News

TZubiritoday at 8:58 AM1 replyview on HN

>Obscurity can be fine but it's not security

You literally just read how Obscurity protected OP in a cybersecurity incident. Now you are just playing word games, which are a waste of time.


Replies

tgvtoday at 9:14 AM

It does seem to be a word game, because "it's not stopping any bullets" either isn't honest (it does stop bullets from hitting you when the enemy doesn't know where to shoot) or it's limited, just like obscurity is ("it may stop a few bullets, but it won't stop all, and there will be other weapons it can't stop either"). I think public key exchange is considered security, but it still requires to obscure your private keys.

Perhaps a better word would be resistance (to intrusion), which is a dimension orthogonal to visibility.